The Best Thermal Carafe Coffee Makers (Review) in 2023

A thermal carafe coffee machine is a convenient type of coffee maker that uses an insulated thermal carafe to keep brewed coffee hot and fresh for a longer period of time. These coffee machines are available in various sizes and styles, ranging from single-serve models to multi-cup brewers. They often come with programmable timers, adjustable brewing strength, and automatic shut-off features. Some models can also make other hot beverages like tea or hot cocoa.

Modern thermal carafe coffee machines are not only functional but also stylish and visually appealing. They typically filter tap water before brewing, rapidly heating it to the ideal temperature of around 200 degrees Fahrenheit to produce a delicious cup of coffee. Some models also allow you to adjust the brewing time or pre-soak the ground beans, giving you more control over the strength of your coffee. Additionally, some coffee machines have a programmable feature that automatically starts brewing at a specific time, while others have an auto-shut-off for safety purposes.

After brewing, the coffee is poured into a highly insulated stainless steel carafe that can keep the coffee hot for up to two hours. Depending on your needs, you can choose between a single cup or up to 10 cups. To help you decide which thermal carafe coffee maker is best for you, take a look at our comprehensive guide to the best thermal carafe coffee makers available on the market.

1.Mr. Coffee Coffee Maker

Indulge in rich and robust coffee flavor with this thermal carafe coffee maker that can brew 10 cups at a time. The brewing process is both speedy and hot, with the temperature exceeding 205 degrees Fahrenheit. The carafe is equipped with double stainless-steel walls, which allows it to retain heat without requiring a warming plate.

If you’re in a hurry, you can pause the brewing process and pour yourself a cup before it finishes. The water reservoir can be easily removed and filled at the sink, and the coffee maker features a clear display that shows you the progress of the brewing process. A cleaning cycle is also included to prevent the buildup of calcium, and a water filter is included to eliminate chlorine that can negatively impact the taste of your coffee. You can even schedule the coffee maker to brew at a specific time.

Key Features:

• Makes 10 cups
• Delivers full flavor coffee
• Keeps coffee warm without a warming plate
• Includes a chlorine filter

2.Cuisinart DCC-3750 Elite 10-Cup Thermal Coffeemaker

Cuisinart is renowned for producing exceptional thermal coffee makers, and this model is no exception. It includes a thermal carafe that can hold up to 10 cups of freshly brewed coffee. The pour spout is drip-free, and the wide-grip handle makes it simple to serve your beverage.

The warming plate is heat-adjustable, and you have the ability to choose the temperature of your brew, whether it be regular, hot, or extra hot. With advanced brewing technology, your coffee will be ready in no time. The machine is fully automated, so you don’t have to do much except input your desired settings. The touchpad controls are user-friendly, and the blue LED display is easy to read. You can select the option to start brewing immediately or schedule it for up to 24 hours in advance. The machine is self-cleaning, and it will automatically shut off after four hours for safety purposes.

You can choose the number of cups you want to brew, as well as the strength of the coffee, which can be regular or bold. To enhance the flavor of your coffee, it passes through a Gold-Tone filter and a charcoal filter before brewing begins.

Key Features:

• Makes up to 10 cups of coffee
• Automatic settings
• Brew start can be delayed
• Self-cleaning

3.BLACK+DECKER 12-Cup Thermal Coffeemaker

Investing in this 12-cup coffee maker with a thermal carafe ensures that there will be plenty of coffee for everyone. The vacuum-sealed carafe has double walls, which keeps your coffee at the perfect temperature for an extended period of time. You have complete control over the brewing process, allowing you to make a smaller amount of coffee (one to four cups) and adjust the strength to your liking. The coffee maker evenly distributes water, resulting in a faster and more flavorful brew.

The no-drip spout eliminates spills, and the wide-mouth design makes cleaning with a damp cloth a breeze. The LED display is large and easy to read, and the buttons are clearly labeled. With just a few button touches, you can adjust everything from the brew time (up to 120 minutes) to the auto-brew function. For added safety, the coffee maker features an auto-shutoff feature.

Key Features:

• Brews 12 cups at a time
• Small volume brew also possible
• Large and clear LED display
• Auto shut off feature

4.OXO Brew 9 Cup Stainless Steel Coffee Maker

This thermal coffee maker has been certified by the Specialty Coffee Association as an exceptional home brewer, ensuring a top-notch cup of coffee every time. It can brew anywhere from two to nine cups of coffee into a highly insulated carafe with double walls, which will keep the coffee warm and tasting fresh.

With just the push of a button, the built-in microprocessor takes care of the rest. It displays the status of the brew and the freshness with an LED backlit interface. The water is heated to between 197.6 and 204.8 degrees F and showered over the coffee grounds to ensure uniform saturation, resulting in a full-bodied flavor. The convenient 24-hour start timer is an added bonus.

Key Features:

• Specialty Coffee Association certified device
• Can brew between two and nine cups of coffee
• Built-in microprocessor
• Uniform saturation of coffee for a full flavor

5.Cuisinart DCC-3400P1 12-Cup Programmable Coffeemaker

The Cuisinart DCC-3400 Thermal Coffee Maker is a versatile machine that allows you to customize your coffee to your preferred temperature. With its internal heating system, you can choose from regular, hot, or extra hot brew settings. The Extreme Brew option employs advanced brewing technology, making your coffee 25 percent faster than standard coffee makers while preserving its delicious taste and aroma.

Our team of product testers reviewed this machine and praised its excellent heat retention, noting that the coffee remained consistently hot. However, it’s worth noting that the carafe is somewhat bulky and heavy, as thermal carafes tend to be heavier than glass ones. Therefore, consider this before purchasing.

This coffee maker has a backlit LCD screen and a 24-hour programmable timer, making it an exceptional model. The thermal carafe is dishwasher safe, and the coffee maker has a self-cleaning feature. Additionally, it comes in seven different colors to choose from, adding to its appeal.

6.French Press Coffee Maker

Grounds or Pods: Grounds | Programmable: N/A | Dimensions: Available in 8, 17, 23, 36, and 44 ounces | Warranty: 5 years | Wattage: N/A | Voltage: N/A

Numerous non-electric coffee makers, including French presses and pour overs, are crafted from thermal materials to retain heat for an extended period. The Frieling Stainless Steel French Press, in particular, can keep coffee piping hot for hours, a feat that glass presses cannot achieve. Our product tester compared the Frieling model to two glass French presses and noted its superior insulation and ability to maintain warmth. To prolong heat retention, rinse the press with hot water beforehand.

As with all French presses, this one must be cleaned or at least rinsed after each use. Although the exterior is prone to smudges, cleaning is simple and uncomplicated, according to our reviewer. The press comes in five sizes, ranging from 8 to 44 ounces, and is available in two finishes: a striking mirrored finish and a more subdued brushed finish. Additionally, both models are dishwasher safe, making cleaning even more effortless.

While the Frieling French press is undoubtedly costly, its exceptional durability may ultimately save money compared to glass presses, which frequently chip or break. However, if this model is too expensive, less expensive thermal French presses are available on the market.

7.Technivorm Moccamaster 79312 KBGT

• Dimensions: 6.7 x 11.5 x 16 inches
• Brew Capacity: 10 cups
• Programmable: No
• Warranty: 5 years

Coffee aficionados worldwide hold Moccamaster coffee makers in high regard, and the KBGT is a personal favorite of Calatrello.

According to her, “Several features distinguish this machine. Firstly, it’s lightning-quick and can brew a full 40-ounce carafe in only 4-6 minutes. Secondly, it boasts a distinctive copper heating element that rapidly heats water to the optimal brewing temperature of 196-205 degrees and shuts off automatically when the reservoir is empty.”

Calatrello appreciates how the Moccamaster KBGT emulates manual brewing, and she confirms that the thermal carafe, when sealed with the provided travel lid, keeps coffee warm for several hours.

8.Keurig K-Duo Plus Coffee Maker

Grounds or Pods: Both | Programmable: Yes | Dimensions: 14.19 x 7.68 x 15.88 inches | Warranty: 1 year | Wattage: 1470 | Voltage: 120

Single-serve coffee makers typically do not require a thermal carafe since they brew directly into your cup. However, the Keurig K-Duo Plus is a rare coffee maker that can brew both a single cup and a full carafe. To brew a full pot of coffee, select a size between 6 to 12 cups and use ground coffee. Alternatively, for a quick cup of joe, insert a K-Cup and choose a size between 6, 8, 10, or 12 ounces.

The K-Duo Plus can be programmed for up to 24 hours, which is standard for most thermal coffee makers but unusual for a Keurig device. It is also more compact than most coffee makers, saving valuable counter space, and has a removable water reservoir that simplifies refilling. Although it may be more expensive than other thermal options, if you prefer a pod-based brewer, this coffee maker is an excellent choice. After testing the K-Duo Plus in her kitchen for several weeks, our expert product tester concluded that it was definitely worth the price. It is easy to set up and use, produces delicious coffee, and includes several extra features.

What to Look for When Buying a Thermal Carafe Coffee Maker

When buying a thermal carafe coffee maker, there are several factors to consider to ensure that you get the best machine for your needs and budget. Here are some things to look for:

• Capacity: Consider how many cups of coffee you typically need to brew at one time. If you have a large household or often entertain, you may want a machine with a larger capacity.
• Brewing options: Some thermal carafe coffee makers have options for brewing regular or bold coffee, as well as small batch sizes. Consider what brewing options you need and whether the machine you are considering offers them.
• Ease of use: Look for a machine that is easy to operate and maintain, with clear instructions and a user-friendly design.
• Durability: Consider the durability of the machine you are considering, as well as its warranty. You may want to read reviews from other users to get an idea of the machine’s reliability.
• Price: Consider your budget and what you are willing to spend on a coffee maker. Keep in mind that more expensive models may come with more features or be more durable, but you may be able to find a good quality machine at a lower price.
• Extra features: Some thermal carafe coffee makers come with additional features, such as programmable timers, automatic shut-off, and built-in water filters. Consider whether these features are important to you and whether the machine you are considering offers them.

Pros and Cons of Thermal Carafe Coffee Makers

Thermal carafe coffee makers are a popular choice for home use because they offer the convenience of being able to brew and serve coffee over an extended period of time without worrying about it getting cold or stale. Here are some pros and cons of using a thermal carafe coffee maker:

Pros:

• Keeps coffee hot and fresh for an extended period of time, making it convenient for serving to a crowd or for multiple coffee drinkers
• Insulated carafes can help to maintain the flavor and quality of the coffee
• Many models have programmable timers and automatic shut-off for convenience
• Comes in a range of sizes and styles to suit different needs and preferences

Cons:

• Some models may be more expensive than non-thermal carafe coffee makers
• Some models may be heavier and bulkier, making them more difficult to store
• Some users may prefer the taste and flavor of coffee brewed in a glass carafe
• The insulation of the carafe may not be as effective at keeping the coffee hot as a traditional heating element
• Thermal carafe coffee makers can be a convenient and practical choice for many people, but it is important to consider the pros and cons before making a decision.

Types of Thermal Carafe Coffee Makers

Drip

Coffee makers with thermal carafes are most commonly drip machines. This is no surprise, considering the immense popularity of drip machines to begin with and that thermal carafes are especially useful for the large batches they brew. These machines can be equipped with a variety of features, from 24-hour programmability to built-in grinders. Prices vary widely in this category, so it is a viable option no matter your budget.

Coffee-and-Espresso Maker

Thermal carafe coffee makers aren’t just limited to drip coffee. Those who enjoy espresso or espresso-based drinks, like lattes and cappuccinos, can find dual-purpose machines that provide all kinds of variety. These devices typically have a split design, featuring a carafe on one side and an espresso maker on the other; though, there are some space-saving options that brew both through the same mechanism. Just keep in mind that coffee-and-espresso makers are usually among the more expensive brewing devices.

Non-Electric

Many non-electric brewing devices are favored among coffee experts, as they allow more control and often a stronger cup. The downside is that they tend to lose temperature quickly since they are not equipped with a hot plate. This isn’t an issue for thermal coffee makers though. In this category, you are primarily looking at French presses and pour overs, both of which can save money and space compared to electric brewers. One quick tip: pour hot water into these devices beforehand and they will retain coffee temperature even longer.

Frequently Asked Questions